Skip to main content

A Pro-Life President?

The presidential election is getting ample coverage at the moment and something crossed my mind after noticing a tweet asking a candidate whether he was pro-life or pro-choice...

The referendum on the 8th amendment passed triumphantly, but the debate on access to abortion is far from over: Some disappointed voters are trying to challenge the result but without damning evidence showing that the referendum's outcome was "materially affected", they won't succeed. More importantly, the proposed piece of legislation which was scrutinised in the campaign must be debated, perhaps amended and eventually passed. Interestingly, Fine Gael and Fianna Fail are giving their TDs and Senators a free vote on the legislation.


One of the few constitutional powers of an Irish President is the ability to refer a bill to the Supreme Court if the President feels that the bill may be unconstitutional. A 7-judge Supreme Court will then sit and review the bill to consider whether it is compatible with Bunreacht na hEireann.

It is likely that the piece of legislation governing access to abortion will pass in the next presidential term. We're not sure if our beloved Michael D Higgins will still hold office (although it is likely that he will). However, in the event that we have a new President, and one who is avowedly pro-life (unlike the socially-left Michael D), they may elect to refer this bill to the Supreme Court for interpretation, perhaps believing that there might be an implied right to life endowed to the unborn which is not enumerated in the Constitution.

It might be worth acknowledging the judgment handed down by the Supreme Court in March of this year which stated that the unborn has no constitutional rights other than those in the 8th amendment, which will not exist by the time that the new piece of legislation is passed, meaning that the unborn will have no constitutional rights whatsoever.

A candidate's views on abortion might be something to take into account when voting for our next President, as this circumstance is a reminder of how the President's constitutional powers can be quite influential when exercised in certain contexts. Even if the Supreme Court upholds the bill, the mere action by a President of referring it for judicial interpretation could leave a sour taste in the mouths of people who voted 'Yes' on May 25th. Do we want a President who is riding the tidal wave of social change in Ireland?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

@rtesecretpro - An account that should never have gotten legs

Recently a controversial Twitter account by the name of ' RTE Secret Producer ' has emerged. Its premise: a brave RTE staff member stands up against their employer and sets out to expose the hidden culture which prevails within the organisation. It sounds like a plot to a low-budget thriller. The account has spurred much debate and has riled up many of the anti-RTE cynics who inhabit our country. Moreover, some of the Irish media - in competition with RTE and unlike RTE, not subsidised by the license fee - are probably happy to have a go at their media nemesis. I have a few thoughts about this Twitter account... First of all  I have read Facebook comment after Facebook comment praising this mystery staffer for their bravery and for being the good Samaritan to expose the ' flawed ' organisation. Although when one examines the level of 'exposure' through the Twitter account, one notices that this secret producer's ramblings amount to little more th...

The 'A Word'

"YOU support murdering children?"   It was a simple exchange. We were talking about faith in the modern world, and I foolishly dropped the 'A Word'. Hinting my feelings in relation to this controversial topic, I was immediately stopped in my tracks. My words had led to a judgement being made about my character and my personality. This headline from Waterford Whispers News summarises what has happened to the debate in Ireland: It's ironic, because since the debate has come into general public consideration in Ireland, it has almost become more of a taboo. A highly emotionally-charged debate, both sides will shoot the other down with provocative statements. People are afraid to open their mouths about it in case they are ridiculed for their views. This is exacerbated by the far-left and far-right musings on social media, suggesting that there is little or no middle-ground in this debate. Whatever side of the tracks you are on, or whether you have made ...

Lyric Hits the Right Note

Why does every radio station play the same music?   Given my occupation, I'm regularly asked naive questions about radio from lay people:  Has anyone ever overheard you in conversation and interjected 'I recognise your voice'?  and Can you get me free tickets to X gig/festival?  are classics. The respective answers are 'No... don't be ridiculous'; and 'No... don't be ridiculous'. There is one question however which comes up regularly enough and I think it's important that it is being asked. Why does every station seem to play music from the likes of Ed Sheeran, Coldplay, Adele and Pink? Have they found the golden formula for pop music? Perhaps they have, but here's the thing. Most music radio stations in Ireland have what's known as an Adult Contemporary format . This was imported from America in the 1980s when aggressive heavy metal and crude rap were emerging as genres, but the soccer moms and 9-5 office workers wanted a more pre...